well yes i'm happy to admit i was ignorant on the subject and that's why i asked, i hope i didn't give off the impression that my opinions were absolute, i tried to take an inquisitive tone with my questions, and the original quote was not my own. i'm no geographer but i honestly thought to myself 'i dont think jamaica is in africa,' so yes i was misunderstood on the history of jamaica.DrYouth wrote: ↑Mon Jan 21, 2019 1:47 pmBasically Pine Apple is probably wondering if she identifies with American Black culure... i.e. blues, hip hop, American urban etc or Jamaican Black culture... i.e. Rastafarian, Reggae, saltfish...
The cultures are pretty different.
But beyond that there is possibility that he thought Jamaicans are an indigenous people of Jamaica...
He's not letting on... which makes me think the latter is more likely.
that being said, my conflict comes more from the social norms that have developed around automatically calling black americans african-american, when not all black americans are african-american or even choose to identify that way. i know it's just a catch-all label but i just wish there wasn't so much emphasis put on it, it feels like there is an extra status implied in the term that wouldn't apply to an indian/jamaican-american.
i dunno man, i don't have my thoughts all sorted out on this subject but identity labels just rub me the wrong way