Okeefenokee wrote:Smitty-48 wrote:I don't get how that points scoring thing works, in my day, the CO decided who got promoted and who didn't, at battalion level. You had to have the qualifications obviously, in terms of taking the course and being current on everything, but otherwise, it was all within the regiment and CO had your career in the palm of his hand.
Points are set by the army according to needs of the army. If the army needs NCOs, points go down until the positions are filled, then they go back up. They are broken down by MOS, rank, and zone.
For instance, you can set the points for an infantry corporal in the primary zone lower than secondary zone if you want to promote younger NCOs, or vice versa.
Promotion eligibility is determined at battalion level promotion boards, but big army says who it wants, so you can stay promotable but not promoted indefinitely if the army doesn't need more NCOs in your job.
OK, I get it now. Ridiculously bureaucratic of course, military as a jobs program uber alles, as if some central authority in Washington knows how many corporals they need in the Army for the purposes of fighting a war, when in fact all they really care about is the careerist pecking order and ticking boxes for the sake of ticking boxes, Army Brass make work, and of course they never ever come to the conclusion that they have exponentially too many Generals, nosiree.
It's even more ridiculous here, Canada has enough Generals to command the People's Liberation Army of China, for what amounts to a single reinforced division in the field, it's just a senior officer public sector pension factory, civil servants in uniform.
The Armies of the West, are good for nothing but the parade square, it's no wonder that goat herders can kick our asses.
And please, don't say "the draft", because that would just make it exponentially worse, that's the ultimate in military social engineering make work, the welfare state in uniform.
We're getting to the point where the expendable mercenaries of the French Foreign Legion are practically the only real soldiers left in the Western World. We should stop pretending that we are maintaining any real armies at all and just turn everything over to the intelligence agencies and the air force. Return all these make work army budgets to the taxpayer says me, I want my money back.
If you ask the Luvvies who rule here "what is the army for?" all they will say is "UN Peacekeeping", in other words "armed virtue signalling", methinks we can dispense with that, thank you.