Poll: Who Supports the Idea of a White Ethno State?

[Hanarchy Montanarchy]

The definition of ethno-state seems to shift around, so it is hard to say.

According to Speaker and Smitty, most states are ethno-states to one degree or another already, so what is the problem? Nobody wants for options of picking their favorite ethno-state.

Unless there is another definition of ethno-state that is a little more vigorous, which I suspect there is.

Derr

Most nations in the world are ethno-states, dude. Pretty much all the nations currently colonizing the western world are ethno-states. There exists no chance we could do to Mexico what the Mexicans are doing to us. The Mexicans would never allow an immigration policy that would render the Mexican people a minority in their own country. If a mob of illegal Anglos tried to illegally detain a Mexican legislator to make all sorts of incoherent demands of "rights" in Mexico, the Federalis would close with extreme brutality. Those Anglos wouldn't return to the states without marks.

Do you think Pakistan will let millions of white people migrate there and become "Pakistanis" just like actual Pakistanis? Of course not. Grow up and get real.

Ethno-state is the default status of humanity. We are a tribal species, genius. If you want to deny nature, then please find your own island to do it on instead of fucking up my country.

Yeah, I get it. You think that basically all states are already ethno-states. Some states actually have laws than enshrine ethnicity, some don't, but they are all ethno-states, kind of, because relatively similar people live in the area.

It is a definition of ethno-state.

[Hanarchy Montanarchy]

I mean.. come on. If Anglos tried to do to Egypt what Muslims are doing here, they'd slam that door shut harder than a shithouse door in a tornado. You'd be out of there after a good bout of torture.

Nobody in their right mind does to their homeland what you are advocating. It's insane.

And yet, nobody is really trying to do that.

I wonder why?

Hmmmmm, what is different about how America is constructed that makes people want to come here? Something sort of unique about how America was constructed, and what principles of statehood it rests on, that makes it the desired destination for much of the world.

HMMMMMMMMMMMMM

[Speaker to Animals]

Invade Japan...

It is just crazy enough to work.

Keep in mind, Japan is fast approaching a real problem in maintaining their ethno-state.

LMFAO

No, they are doing just fine.

They are not buying what you are selling here. The Japanese people I interact with are all like "wtf is going on? Why is America doing this to themselves?"

I think the just dropped to less than a million births for the first time pretty recently.

Gonna be hard to maintain that ethno-state without the requisite ethno to protect with the state.

They will be fine. They already are beginning the process of automating everything. They will hit the demographic winter and then carry on, still in possession of their own nation.

Us on the other hand.. we are having to figure out how not get to offed like the Jews when we no longer have any nations of our own.

[Speaker to Animals]

I mean.. come on. If Anglos tried to do to Egypt what Muslims are doing here, they'd slam that door shut harder than a shithouse door in a tornado. You'd be out of there after a good bout of torture.

Nobody in their right mind does to their homeland what you are advocating. It's insane.

And yet, nobody is really trying to do that.

I wonder why?

Hmmmmm, what is different about how America is constructed that makes people want to come here? Something sort of unique about how America was constructed, and what principles of statehood it rests on, that makes it the desired destination for much of the world.

HMMMMMMMMMMMMM

Hmmmm


Maybe it's because we have no real immigration policy??

And if you mean to imply that Arabs tend to turn nations into horrific shitholes, then why in the name of Mohammed's anus should we allow any of them to come here??

[Hanarchy Montanarchy]

LMFAO

No, they are doing just fine.

They are not buying what you are selling here. The Japanese people I interact with are all like "wtf is going on? Why is America doing this to themselves?"

I think the just dropped to less than a million births for the first time pretty recently.

Gonna be hard to maintain that ethno-state without the requisite ethno to protect with the state.

They will be fine. They already are beginning the process of automating everything. They will hit the demographic winter and then carry on, still in possession of their own nation.

Us on the other hand.. we are having to figure out how not get to offed like the Jews when we no longer have any nations of our own.

Ethnic nationalism will work because robots.

Noted.

[Smitty-48]

The definition of ethno-state seems to shift around, so it is hard to say.

According to Speaker and Smitty, most states are ethno-states to one degree or another already, so what is the problem? Nobody wants for options of picking their favorite ethno-state.

Unless there is another definition of ethno-state that is a little more vigorous, which I suspect there is.

Well, you're opposed to a white ethno state in America, that's the "vigorous" definition that sets off your SIFCLF gene, cause you're an American lefty, and you American lefties have liberal white guilt, over Jim Crow and whanot, and so there is a double standard with you, whereas in Quebec, while there are a lot of lefties, they don't have that liberal white guilt, their French ethno state uber alles doctrine overrides all other concerns.

Now, it would be possible for America to adopt the Canadian Deux Solitudes doctrine, it's not against the laws of physics, and the sky wouldn't fall, but you American lefties can't have that, because you've got both the liberal white guilt gene, and the SIFCLF gene, so any talk of a Quebec for American whitey, of course incites you into an hysterical response.

It wouldn't abridge your rights anymore than Quebec abridges my rights, rather in fact, Quebec actually underpins my rights, just having Quebec around means the rest of us are more free to be independent, it wouldn't be a failed state anymore than Quebec is a failed state, they're in an economic boom right now, and it wouldn't have to incite a conflict, unless of course you American lefties chose to start one, because once American Whitey had a Quebec of his very own, he wouldn't have any cause to fight with you anymore, same as Quebec has no cause to fight with me.

I would submit, the ideal location for American Quebec, would arguably be Idaho, there's only a million people there right now, 90% white, 0.6% black, just make Idaho the White Ethno State, let the white ethno nationalists have it as a Quebec of their very own, give them a Notwithstanding Clause to opt out of federal rulings as they see fit; problem solved.

[Hanarchy Montanarchy]

The definition of ethno-state seems to shift around, so it is hard to say.

According to Speaker and Smitty, most states are ethno-states to one degree or another already, so what is the problem? Nobody wants for options of picking their favorite ethno-state.

Unless there is another definition of ethno-state that is a little more vigorous, which I suspect there is.

Well, you're opposed to a white ethno state in America, that's the "vigorous" definition that sets off your SIFCLF gene, cause you're an American lefty, and you American lefties have liberal white guilt, over Jim Crow and whanot, and so there is a double standard with you, whereas in Quebec, while there are a lot of lefties, they don't have that liberal white guilt, their French ethno state uber alles doctrine overrides all other concerns.

Now, it would be possible for America to adopt the Canadian Deux Solitudes doctrine, it's not against the laws of physics, and the sky wouldn't fall, but you American lefties can't have that, because you've got both the liberal white guilt gene, and the SIFCLF gene, so any talk of a Quebec for American whitey, of course incites you into an hysterical response.

I argued that America wan't an ethno state already, and that how America is constructed prevents it from being an ethno state.

It was many, many, many pages back, but I argued that the reason I didn't want a piece of America carved out now as a white ethno state was that I didn't think the people who wanted it were willing to foot the bill for creating it, and that I didn't want to pay for it since I think there are better things to spend our money on.

However, if it was proposed, and democratically decided that we were going to move in that direction, I wouldn't revolt. I think that is within the far outside range of possibilities.

Not a big guilt person. But, you are free not to believe that either.

[Smitty-48]

I argued that America wan't an ethno state already, and that how America is constructed prevents it from being an ethno state.

It was many, many, many pages back, but I argued that the reason I didn't want a piece of America carved out now as a white ethno state was that I didn't think the people who wanted it were willing to foot the bill for creating it, and that I didn't want to pay for it since I think there are better things to spend our money on.

However, if it was proposed, and democratically decided that we were going to move in that direction, I wouldn't revolt. I think that is within the far outside range of possibilities.

Not a big guilt person. But, you are free not to believe that either.

Oh please, you would revolt, you'd be right there with the rest of the "Democratic Socialists" calling it "Nazi America", but if you simply allowed Idaho to be the White Ethno State in America, the ethno nationalists would flock there like the Jews flock to Zion, just let them have their Quebec, and they'll be happy, and they'll stop bothering people about it.

It's only you lefties and the cucks who would try to oppose it; the vast majority of Red Staters would oppose making Idaho into the White State like a indigenous reserve for Anglo-European types? Nonsense, they'd be all over that, it's only the American liberal white guilt complex, and the black race hustling, that is standing in the way of Crackuh Nirvana.

This is what the Alt Right has to do, they have to have a tangible place they can point to, an actual place to call Zion, Idaho is perfect, they need to get off the theoretical, and actually pick a place to be their Quebec, to make it into a self fulfilling prophecy, and then just start moving there en masse, until they take over by default, Operation Exodus, like the Israelis did.

[Hanarchy Montanarchy]

More lefty bullshit, if you simply allowed Idaho to be the White Ethno State in America, the ethno nationalists would flock there like the Jews flock to Zion, just let them have their Quebec, and they'll be happy, and they'll stop bothering people about it.

It's only you lefties and the cucks who would try to oppose it; the vast majority of Red Staters would oppose making Idaho into the White State like a indigenous reserve for Anglo-European types? Nonsense, they'd be all over that, it's only the American liberal white guilt complex, and the black race hustling, that is standing in the way of Crackuh Nirvana.

Allowed? I wasn't aware that Idaho's population was interested in doing that.

Idaho is pretty far down on the list of states by GDP. If this is just going to turn into an expensive ass ache like Israel, I'd still like to know who is paying for the fiasco if The Republic of Idaho is gonna keep coming back, year after year, for more handouts.

But I am not an accountant. Like I said, if someone works up a realistic proposal with a reasonable price tag, and it is decided, democratically, to carve out Idaho, and Idaho's current residents are cool with it, I won't kick off or anything.

I probably wouldn't vote for it, since the price tag would have to be pretty friggin low for me to imagine it is worth it, and, frankly, I don't believe the people that move into the New Free Republic of Idaho would just shut up and be happy because bitchin' and moanin' seems to be wired into human nature.
I mean, you got people who believe living in America is a raw deal, so how good a deal do you have to give them before they're happy and they stop bothering everyone?

[Smitty-48]

There's three things which America is missing, to make America just right, one is an all White State, which I would make Idaho, the other is an all Black State, which I would make Mississippi, and the third is a coast-to-coast Autobahn, no speed limits.

You wouldn't have to live in the White State, blacks wouldn't have to live in the Black State, and if people like to drive 55, they don't have to get on the autobahn, but the option would be there, for those who want a Quebec of their very own, and who like to drive fast and free.