The left vs the 23% white separatist contingent

[SuburbanFarmer]

Just so I get the facts straight: That the French are white, does that make their whiteness an ethnicity too, though? Do French-Canadians iow have two ethnicities, or is French an ethnicity and "White" maybe the name of something other than an ethnicity?

French is the predominant ethnicity in Quebec.
White is predominant race in Quebec.
Not all White Ethno States are French Ethno States.
Not all French Ethno States are White Ethno States.
Quebec is both a French Ethno State and a White Ethno State.

See how that works? It isn't rocket science, you guys are overthinking things.

Capps, in your opinion, what are some non-white ethno states in the current world? Do any exist? Do you consider Japan one?

Apparently, any country with a majority black population is a "Black Ethno-State", so... most of Africa?

[heydaralon]

French is the predominant ethnicity in Quebec.
White is predominant race in Quebec.
Not all White Ethno States are French Ethno States.
Not all French Ethno States are White Ethno States.
Quebec is both a French Ethno State and a White Ethno State.

See how that works? It isn't rocket science, you guys are overthinking things.

Capps, in your opinion, what are some non-white ethno states in the current world? Do any exist? Do you consider Japan one?

Apparently, any country with a majority black population is a "Black Ethno-State", so... most of Africa?

Maybe by default idk. I thought that South Africa, despite the policies it enacts, explicitly does not define itself as an ehtno-state. The flag is supposed to represent as much, as well as the Truth and Reconciliation Commission that happened in the 90's. Mandela wasn't much of a leader imo, but his (stated maybe not practiced) goal was to bring the diverse groups in the country together.

[StCapps]

Just so I get the facts straight: That the French are white, does that make their whiteness an ethnicity too, though? Do French-Canadians iow have two ethnicities, or is French an ethnicity and "White" maybe the name of something other than an ethnicity?

French is the predominant ethnicity in Quebec.
White is predominant race in Quebec.
Not all White Ethno States are French Ethno States.
Not all French Ethno States are White Ethno States.
Quebec is both a French Ethno State and a White Ethno State.

See how that works? It isn't rocket science, you guys are overthinking things.

Capps, in your opinion, what are some non-white ethno states in the current world? Do any exist? Do you consider Japan one?

Japan, South Korea, China and India are some examples Non-White Jus Sanguinis Ethno States.

[StCapps]

Apparently, any country with a majority black population is a "Black Ethno-State", so... most of Africa?

Some African nations are Black Ethno States, but not any country with a majority black population is automatically a Ethno State by default. But yeah any country with majority black population that also happens to be an Ethno State, is a Black Ethno State. Haiti is an example of Jus Sanguinis Black Ethno State.

[heydaralon]

French is the predominant ethnicity in Quebec.
White is predominant race in Quebec.
Not all White Ethno States are French Ethno States.
Not all French Ethno States are White Ethno States.
Quebec is both a French Ethno State and a White Ethno State.

See how that works? It isn't rocket science, you guys are overthinking things.

Capps, in your opinion, what are some non-white ethno states in the current world? Do any exist? Do you consider Japan one?

Japan, South Korea, China and India are some examples Non-White Jus Sanguinis Ethno States.

India is a bit trickier imo, because they have castes, muslims, and hindus. From my limited understanding, the caste system is about the same as a race over there, but that gets us into all kinds of weird discussions on race v. class. I don't fully get how you would define an ethno state if you already have different ethnic groups living there. Japan is an insular culture on an island in a position to restrict Gaijin, but many places already have diverse people living there. Even China is not really homogenous, with the Hmong, Cantonese, Uighurs etc. Those dudes living in the gobi desert are so far from what we view as sterotypically Chinese, they might as well be a different group.

[StCapps]

India is a bit trickier imo, because they have castes, muslims, and hindus. From my limited understanding, the caste system is about the same as a race over there, but that gets us into all kinds of weird discussions on race v. class. I don't fully get how you would define an ethno state if you already have different ethnic groups living there. Japan is an insular culture on an island in a position to restrict Gaijin, but many places already have diverse people living there. Even China is not really homogenous, with the Hmong, Cantonese, Uighurs etc. Those dudes living in the gobi desert are so far from what we view as sterotypically Chinese, they might as well be a different group.

Other ethnic groups living among the ethnic majority in an Ethno State, does not disqualify a state from being an Ethno State.

[Speaker to Animals]

nah. Castes are separate from race. Non-Indians are called raksasa or something like that. Basically foreign demons.

Also, the Muslims for the part are the same race. They just converted to Islam. There are Christians too. Same race, though.

[SuburbanFarmer]

Hey, member that time I posted a definition of Ethno-State?

ethnostate
English
Etymology

ethno- +‎ state
Noun

ethnostate (plural ethnostates)

A political unit that is populated by and run in the interest of an ethnic group

Yeahhhh... I member.

[StCapps]

Hey, member that time I posted a definition of Ethno-State?

ethnostate
English
Etymology

ethno- +‎ state
Noun

ethnostate (plural ethnostates)

A political unit that is populated by and run in the interest of an ethnic group

Yeahhhh... I member.

Notice how the definition doesn't only include "....run in the interests of all ethnic groups of the same race", that is only one particular variety of ethnostate, yet some folks seem to think it's the only kind of ethno state that there is.

[heydaralon]

Hey, member that time I posted a definition of Ethno-State?

ethnostate
English
Etymology

ethno- +‎ state
Noun

ethnostate (plural ethnostates)

A political unit that is populated by and run in the interest of an ethnic group

Yeahhhh... I member.

I don't speak English well, and my browser blocks meriam webster.com because some Nigerian scammers fleeced me for 2K when I clicked a banner ad on there. No reason to be a dick about it.