The Conservative wrote:Martin Hash wrote:I'm repeatedly on the record for truly socialized Social Security. No pensions, period. If people want an annuity during retirement, they can pay for it from the extra money their employer gives them to do that.
Has people ever thought about entrusting this to something like a Credit Union? I have a business account with a credit union, and I put a few hundred a month towards my own pension.
Why can't we trust something like that?
Most people, left to their own choices, wouldn't save shit. I've known lots of people who never contributed to their (available) 401k... I had two friends that got divorced a decade ago now, they were in hock up to their eyeballs (leased BMW for him when he was a consultant for IBM - pretty much drove it to the airport Sunday night to fly somewhere, and back Friday on a redeye, and then to the golf course Saturday, but he needed it for "comfort"
, even the place carpet in their dining room was on a payment plan... they did twice yearly bulk meat deliveries, rented the chest freezer for $100/mo for *7 years* - they could've bought 5 of them for what they paid in that time). I finally convinced them to enroll to get at least the 3% match, two years before they divorced, and they both cashed it out during the divorce. She kept the underwater house for like 4 years before walking away on it with $30k in CC debt.
Most people would simply take any money their employer gave them and spend it on "things today" and have nothing for retirement. Heck, I have several ex-Gfs that were lucky to have 30k saved for retirement by age 50... but they had the camper, the boat, bought cars for their kids, etc.
I paid my 30yr mortgage off in 12 years *and* was putting 10-15% in my 401k the whole time - every GF in that time tried to convince me to lower my 401k contributions and not pay extra on the house... to have more to spend on them and "enjoy it more" - probably why I'm still single.