Does this poll reveal the number of white separatists ion the board?

[StCapps]

Doesn't work that way.

You learned a bunch of bullshit, race isn't more important than culture.

[Fife]

Culture is downstream of race.

Normally, I would tell you to sober up. Actually, you should probably just triple down.

[Speaker to Animals]

Question: why do racial minorities in general create subcultures?

[TheReal_ND]

None of those replies are arguments. Just name calling and derision. First response that comes from somebody that has been conditioned in such a manner. That's what keeps you from thinking about it. You immediately think it's wrong. NO ZAP. Usually this will be followed up by "not all are x," if you aren't immediately thinking of white trash already. I know how it goes, it's ok really, I've accepted this is how it is and moved on.

[Fife]

Question: why do racial minorities in general create subcultures?

Why do competing products press prices downwards and outputs upwards?

For a smartassed Catholic, you make me wonder if you've actually read much of the bible sometimes.

[DBTrek]

Actually, my first thought was on the evolution of culture from the division of labor c. 10,000BC to Marxism c.1848AD, and how each cultural advance was neither race dependent, nor did new races appear to assume the role of upstream cultural "source".

As I said, provably false.

[Speaker to Animals]

Problem for civic nationalists here is that culture really is to some extent tied to race. Racial groups in any multi-racial society tend to develop into separate sub-cultures.

[StCapps]

Problem for civic nationalists here is that culture really is to some extent tied to race. Racial groups in any multi-racial society tend to develop into separate sub-cultures.

That is because they had a different culture than most folks in the racial majority, not because they were a different race from the majority, stop putting the cart before the horse.

[Speaker to Animals]

Problem for civic nationalists here is that culture really is to some extent tied to race. Racial groups in any multi-racial society tend to develop into separate sub-cultures.

That is because they had a different culture than most folks in the racial majority, not because they were a different race from the majority, stop putting the cart before the horse.

American blacks had no other culture. We stripped their ancestors of religion, culture, history, and values. They still created their own subculture.

Again: if race has no bearing on culture, then you wouldn't see different races in a multi-racial society with distinct cultures.

You can't sit here and shit all over Nukedog's assertion without a shred of argument, and then pretend like all these obvious examples don't exist. Does black culture not exist? Of course it does.

[Fife]

Problem for civic nationalists here is that culture really is to some extent tied to race. Racial groups in any multi-racial society tend to develop into separate sub-cultures.

What's your solution regarding "separate sub-cultures?"

Be specific.