The left vs the 23% white separatist contingent

[StCapps]

I think I see the problem now. We're obviously giving StA/StCapps too much credit. They haven't thought through their ideas.

So let's break it down to kinder-blocks.

1 - Seal off the borders completely. No new immigrants for.... 30 years.
2 - Watch the demographics. Brown-skins continue to impregnate and be impregnated by white-skins.
3 - America turns light-brown.
4 - StA/Cappy see this happening, and lose their shit.
5 - Re-segregate the schools and society.
6 - Welcome back to the 50s!

Strawman City. Get your reading comprehension checked.

[Hanarchy Montanarchy]

Most ethno states aren't a dystopia, the historical record is on my side. Just because the Palestinians are pissed off about the existence of a Jewish Ethno State, that doesn't prove you right.

There are more Quebec's in the historical record when it comes to Ethno States than Nazi Germany, nice try SIFCLF.

Most ethno-states weren't created through partition and balkanization. They grew up around an existing homogeneous group, or out of a colony with existing, separate, laws.

This isn't what would be happening in the US. The historical record, the actual one, not the counterfactual one in your imagination, is not on your side.

Creating new states is not a peaceful process, as a general rule.

Actually, yeah, for the most part, that's exactly how nation states are formed. Poland and Lithuania are two separate nations now for a reason. Scotland is free to fuck off from England for a reason. I don't see Serbia as part of Austria and I can name about six little nations of people who want fuck all to do with Russia.

Well, see, now we have gotten back to the fact that you seem to define almost all nation states as ethno-states.

And, the history of Serbia and Austria isn't rosy. In fact, the whole of the Balkans has been less than rosy, which is why the sort of Balkanization being suggested is usually treated with, at least, a little suspicion. The current situation between Russian and ex-USSR states isn't rosy. The history of England and Ireland or Scotland, or the US isn't rosy.

Peaceful partition is the exception.

[DBTrek]

:lol:

Sad.

Pages and pages with still no answer on how StA will mitigate Latino domestic birth rates hitting 51% with his mandated white majority US rule.

But if he just rages hard enough for another 20 pages maybe he can pull in another low-info doofus like StCapps to rally.

Rage on, clown.
America isn’t even listening to you.
(But Canadian doofuses are, so it’s a start)

[StCapps]

@Hanarchy
You seem surprised that there have been lots of Ethno States in history, that also weren't a dystopia. That should not be news.
/shrugs

[SuburbanFarmer]

@Hanarchy
You seem surprised that there have been lots of Ethno States in history, that also weren't a dystopia. That should not be news.
/shrugs

Could that be because they... started that way?

[StCapps]

@Hanarchy
You seem surprised that there have been lots of Ethno States in history, that also weren't a dystopia. That should not be news.
/shrugs

Could that be because they... started that way?

In some cases yes, in some cases no. This assumption that forming an Ethno State from scratch automatically leads to dystopia, simply not backed by the historical record.

[K@th]

@Hanarchy
You seem surprised that there have been lots of Ethno States in history, that also weren't a dystopia. That should not be news.
/shrugs

I'm not convinced that's relevant. The United States has never been an all white country.

[Hanarchy Montanarchy]

@Hanarchy
You seem surprised that there have been lots of Ethno States in history, that also weren't a dystopia. That should not be news.
/shrugs

Not at all. I am just surprised that people believe that creating states doesn't usually have violence for a handmaiden.

[DBTrek]

No one is surprised that homogenous nations with 95%+ demographic conformity aren’t dystopias, Capps. We’re surprised that you’re so stupid you think that factoid applies to America.

[StCapps]

@Hanarchy
You seem surprised that there have been lots of Ethno States in history, that also weren't a dystopia. That should not be news.
/shrugs

I'm not convinced that's relevant. The United States has never been an all white country.

And it never will be, even if you took my advice.
/shrugs