The left vs the 23% white separatist contingent

[StCapps]

So your answer is change our constitution? LOL....

In other words, you have absolutely no idea how to maintain the white majority in the USA.

Quebec is a province, you can have one state become a White Ethno State, you don't need the entire country to become one.

Forced relocation of the nonwhites in that state or strip them of US citizenship? Or something more drastic?

Not dystopian at all.

Derp.

No forced relocation required, captain strawman. A white ethno state does not mean that only whites can live in the state.

[K@th]

So your answer is change our constitution? LOL....

In other words, you have absolutely no idea how to maintain the white majority in the USA.

Quebec is a province, you can have one state become a White Ethno State, you don't need the entire country to become one. That is far more viable than a nationwide White Ethno State.

You need a police state to enforce it, though.

[StCapps]

You need a police state to enforce it, though.

Real life examples say otherwise, you are just determined to think that it automatically results in a dystopia, even when numerous modern examples prove you wrong, including Quebec.

[Speaker to Animals]

StA: Keep America white!!!

Me: What do you do to our fellow Latino citizens when they hit 51% to enforce your race rule?

StA: Blaaarrrggghh blarrrghhhh blarrrrrghhhh (meltdown)

Me: If they reach 51% rule, it's over. They are going to open the floodgates for total colonization from the Hispanic world to replace you. Anti-white policies will remain in place even though you daughters will be minorities.

Oh.. also.. Me: this debate isn't about what happens if Latinos become a majority. It's about halting the immigration, taxation, and family court policies designed to make that happen so that it does NOT happen.


And you still failed to defend the proposition that whites should be made a minority. You can't both be against the proposition that whites should remain a majority and the proposition that whites should be made a minority. It violates the most fundamental axiom of logic (noncontradiction).

[Hanarchy Montanarchy]

We were talking about maintaining a white majority in America. You started talking about Quebec for some totally unaccountable reason.

Quebec has maintained a white french speaking majority in Quebec, it did not require a dystopia to achieve it. Stop assuming a dystopia is necessary to achieve a White Ethno State in America, fucking SIFCLF's.

You have a few states that are already over 90% white, just have one of those states be the White Ethno State, give them a Notwithstanding Clause, no dystopia required. If y'all knew anything about Quebec, you would realize that maintaining a White Ethno State doesn't require the extreme measures a lot of you seem to envision.

Since we are in imagination land, sure, I am sure it is just as easy as that.

That sounds a lot like how people described how easy the Palestinian two state solution would be, but, never mind that. Never mind the difference in Canadian law, and the history of French colonies there. It will all be very easy, and if you suggest it won't be a total and complete cake walk, and bring up countless examples of two state solutions and balkanizations that weren't cake walks, well, maybe we will get to hear that terribly witty acronym for the umpteenth time.

[StCapps]

Since we are in imagination land, sure, I am sure it is just as easy as that.

That sounds a lot like how people described how easy the Palestinian two state solution would be, but, never mind that. Never mind the difference in Canadian law, and the history of French colonies there. It will all be very easy, and if you suggest it won't be a total and complete cake walk, and bring up countless examples of two state solutions and balkanizations that weren't cake walks, well, maybe we will get to hear that terribly witty acronym for the umpteenth time.

My position is not that it would be easy for America to do, in fact it would be harder to do in America than most majority white nations, my position is that a dystopia isn't required to create a White Ethno State, and any assumptions to the contrary are not well founded, as numerous real life examples show.

You might live in imagination land, but the historical record proves your dystopic assumptions about creating Ethno States to be quite faulty.

[K@th]

So now you agree it would be very difficult to do, here. Then, why are you arguing that it would be easy? /sigh

[StCapps]

So now you agree it would be very difficult to do, here. Then, why are you arguing that it would be easy? /sigh

If y'all made the necessary changes, then it would be easy.

What's hard is: getting America to take that advice and actually implement it, I never said that wasn't a major issue, in fact I have pointed that out to both StA and nukedog on several occassions, it would be easier if they just moved to Quebec, than starting from scratch in America.

[DBTrek]

The Constitution is currently neutral on racial majorities. So I’ve no obligation to defend Americanism along racial lines. You’re the one calling for mandated racial majorities, and that’s unAmerican.

You want immigration control, I’m probably in. You want to move non citizens out? I’m probably in. You want to make American synonymous with being white? I’m out. And I suspect any American in their right mind is also out.

[StCapps]

You want to make American synonymous with being white? I’m out. And I suspect any American in their right mind is also out.

Not what I am proposing.