Maybe it's not Capitalism or Liberalism

[DrYouth]

Technically you could do something like that in the US... With Germans or something.

Please provide a specific referent for "you" in that (sort of) sentence.

I'm just trying to catch up with the counterfactuals y'all are playing with.

What the hell do I know who "you" is supposed to be?

German Americans? Maybe they will band together and create their own Vaterland up in Michigan...

That would be an eye opener!

[Hanarchy Montanarchy]

IIRC, it was supposed to be Iowa.

[K@th]

I'm just trying to catch up with the counterfactuals y'all are playing with.

There's something like three people on this forum who want to live in "Only Whites Allowed" country. The rest of us don't base a person's character on melanin levels.

[SuburbanFarmer]

Is this the proper time to note that “German” is a recent conglomeration of dozens of different nationalities, and several distinct cultures?

34062DEF-A9FC-4B37-BACB-B600EEE927AA.jpeg

[StCapps]

I'm just trying to catch up with the counterfactuals y'all are playing with.

There's something like three people on this forum who want to live in "Only Whites Allowed" country. The rest of us don't base a person's character on melanin levels.

Pretty sure no one on this forum wants to live in a "Only Whites Allowed" country, stop demonizing those you disagree with via ridiculous strawmen.

[StCapps]

Is this the proper time to note that “German” is a recent conglomeration of dozens of different nationalities, and several distinct cultures?

34062DEF-A9FC-4B37-BACB-B600EEE927AA.jpeg

Back in the day, Germany wasn't even a country! How enlightening.

[DrYouth]

I'm just trying to catch up with the counterfactuals y'all are playing with.

There's something like three people on this forum who want to live in "Only Whites Allowed" country. The rest of us don't base a person's character on melanin levels.

If "white" translated to some sort of culture... I could understand the desire to preserve it.
Preserving culture makes a lot of sense to me... preserving genetic monolithism makes a lot less sense, unless you like rare diseases.

Now there is a cultural piece here...
Christian culture... but this is very diverse, and has never been based on ethnicity - unlike Judaism for example.
Southern culture... a dicey issue, given it's strong association with racial subjugation, but there is something beyond racial subjugation that is not at all meaningless.
British culuture - American culture was a rejection of this.
Native American culture - not much to say here - American culture was also a rejection of this.

American culture I would say is about human liberty, cultivating an entrepreneurial spirit and welcoming immigration as much as any notion of whiteness.

What else?
I throw the floor open to all of you.

[K@th]

]Pretty sure no one on this forum wants to live in a "Only Whites Allowed" country, stop demonizing those you disagree with via ridiculous strawmen.

They just want to enact policies to ensure nobody non-white can migrate here.

[StCapps]

I'm just trying to catch up with the counterfactuals y'all are playing with.

There's something like three people on this forum who want to live in "Only Whites Allowed" country. The rest of us don't base a person's character on melanin levels.

If "white" translated to some sort of culture... I could understand the desire to preserve it.
Preserving culture makes a lot of sense to me... preserving genetic monolithism makes a lot less sense, unless you like rare diseases.

Now there is a cultural piece here...
Christian culture... but this is very diverse, and has never been based on ethnicity - unlike Judaism for example.
Southern culture... a dicey issue, given it's strong association with racial subjugation, but there is something beyond racial subjugation that is not at all meaningless.
British culuture - American culture was a rejection of this.
Native American culture - not much to say here - American culture was also a rejection of this.

What else?
I throw the floor open to all of you.

Careful Dr. Y, not slamming a White Ethno State hard enough will cause Kath to pretend that you want to live in "Only White's Allowed" society, that's the only way she can fool herself into thinking she won the argument, argue against idiotic strawmen.

[StCapps]

]Pretty sure no one on this forum wants to live in a "Only Whites Allowed" country, stop demonizing those you disagree with via ridiculous strawmen.

They just want to enact policies to ensure nobody non-white can migrate here.

StA wants to stop white immigration too, didn't you hear, America doesn't need no stinking immigration of any kind, according to StA. You are deliberately mischaracterizing his position in order to have a stupid position to argue against, but he has plenty of stupid positions to criticize without pretending he said something that he didn't, so no need to reach.