Should Kath Be Allowed To Continue As Moderator?

[Montegriffo]

Kath is learning from Trump's art of the deal 4d chess tactics.
Threaten moderation in order to acheive the lesser aim of stopping NHL spam infesting one single Olympics thread. Capps is acting like an SJW snowflake so butt hurt that he can not see what a douchebag he looks like.
It remains to be seen whether Kath will carry out her threat but this has not stopped Capps from making a fool of himself. Sad.

[DrYouth]

Stop listening to Kath's interpretation for the reasons I'm started this thread, or monte's, they couldn't be more wrong about why I actually started this thread. Kath was just paranoid about not having an Olympic thread that goes the way she wants, and was so butthurt about that, that she threatened to use her powers selectively to impose a safe space on the forum, to ensure at least Olympic thread would go the way she wanted, and now her paranoid reaction has created a self fulfilling prophecy. I would have been nice, but then censorship was threatened, to try and make me be nice.

I am listening to your side... that's why I asked you to give it.
My summary so far.

You didn't respect the thread. Posting off content material repeatedly and gratuitously.
And didn't respond to being called out on that.
That's bad. 1 point against Cappy
(I find your incessant NHL chat in threads you don't like annoying too... this isn't the first time you two have done that... I have to scroll past all your posts to keep up with the thread... keep it to an NHL thread.)

Kath threatened censorship when you wouldn't respond to her requests.
Threatening censorship is bad... 2 points against Kath.

You then tried to start a forum referendum to get fired Kath by Marty so that you wouldn't be threatened any more...
And took no responsibility for your initial infraction.... 3 points against Cappy.

Score is at 2:4...

Not a blow out by any means.... but game Kath so far... IMHO
Feel free to contest my scoring and I am happy to modify it with more incoming information.

[StCapps]

Kath is learning from Trump's art of the deal 4d chess tactics.
Threaten moderation in order to acheive the lesser aim of stopping NHL spam infesting one single Olympics thread. Capps is acting like an SJW snowflake so butt hurt that he can not see what a douchebag he looks like.
It remains to be seen whether Kath will carry out her threat but this has not stopped Capps from making a fool of himself. Sad.

I didn't threaten censorship, hence she is far more butthurt than I.

[K@th]

via Imgflip Meme Generator

[StCapps]

Stop listening to Kath's interpretation for the reasons I'm started this thread, or monte's, they couldn't be more wrong about why I actually started this thread. Kath was just paranoid about not having an Olympic thread that goes the way she wants, and was so butthurt about that, that she threatened to use her powers selectively to impose a safe space on the forum, to ensure at least Olympic thread would go the way she wanted, and now her paranoid reaction has created a self fulfilling prophecy. I would have been nice, but then censorship was threatened, to try and make me be nice.

You didn't respect the thread. Posting off content material repeatedly and gratuitously.
And didn't respond to being called out on that.
That's bad. 1 point against Cappy
(I find your incessant NHL chat in threads you don't like annoying too... this isn't the first time you two have done that... I have to scroll past all your posts to keep up with the thread... keep it to an NHL thread.)

Kath threatened censorship when you wouldn't respond to her requests.
Threatening censorship is bad... 2 points against Kath.

You then tried to start a forum referendum to get fired Kath by Marty so that you wouldn't be threatened any more...
And took no responsibility for your initial infraction.... 3 points against Cappy.

Score is at 2:5...

Not a blow out by any means.... but game Kath so far... IMHO

I'm not trying to get her fired, I just think she should be given her inclination to selectively censor those whose posts she doesn't like, and if Martin Hash isn't a hypocrite, he would agree.

Your score keeping sucks balls. I took responsibility for my actions, I just don't take kindly to threats of censorship, you aren't even paying attention to what happened and are excepting Kath and Monte's version of events.

[DrYouth]

I'm not trying to get her fired, I just think she should be and if Martin Hash isn't a hypocrite, he would agree. Your score keeping sucks balls.

No new info in that post...
But I did miscount the points...
2:4

The score stands.

I vote that Kath remains.
I also agree that you should keep your NHL chatter to NHL threads...
If you forget to that's fine...
If you are reminded of it... I would expect you would respect the wishes of any poster in a specified thread... including Kath.

[K@th]

via Imgflip Meme Generator

[StCapps]

I'm not trying to get her fired, I just think she should be and if Martin Hash isn't a hypocrite, he would agree. Your score keeping sucks balls.

No new info in that post...
But I did miscount the points...
2:4

The score stands.

Still terrible score keeping. I was going to let them have their thread, but then war was declared by threatening censorship, and now it's war.

[Montegriffo]

Stop listening to Kath's interpretation for the reasons I'm started this thread, or monte's, they couldn't be more wrong about why I actually started this thread. Kath was just paranoid about not having an Olympic thread that goes the way she wants, and was so butthurt about that, that she threatened to use her powers selectively to impose a safe space on the forum, to ensure at least Olympic thread would go the way she wanted, and now her paranoid reaction has created a self fulfilling prophecy. I would have been nice, but then censorship was threatened, to try and make me be nice.

I am listening to your side... that's why I asked you to give it.
My summary so far.

You didn't respect the thread. Posting off content material repeatedly and gratuitously.
And didn't respond to being called out on that.
That's bad. 1 point against Cappy
(I find your incessant NHL chat in threads you don't like annoying too... this isn't the first time you two have done that... I have to scroll past all your posts to keep up with the thread... keep it to an NHL thread.)

Kath threatened censorship when you wouldn't respond to her requests.
Threatening censorship is bad... 2 points against Kath.

You then tried to start a forum referendum to get fired Kath by Marty so that you wouldn't be threatened any more...
And took no responsibility for your initial infraction.... 3 points against Cappy.

Score is at 2:4...

Not a blow out by any means.... but game Kath so far... IMHO
Feel free to contest my scoring and I am happy to modify it with more incoming information.

Dr Youth's scorekeeping maths 5/10.
Rational interpretation of the issue 10/10

[K@th]

via Imgflip Meme Generator